All Cheeses
- Smoked Provolone by Red Apple Cheese
- Smoked Red Fox by Belton Farm
- Smoked Seaside Rugged Mature English Cheddar by Ford Farm
- Smoked Sharp Cheddar by Old Croc
- Smoked Sheep Milk Gouda by Hook's Cheese Company
- Smoked Swiss by Red Apple Cheese
- Smokehouse by Bear State Farms
- Smokey Blue by Rogue Creamery
- Smokey Mountain Round by Goat Lady Dairy
- Smoking Cow Raw Milk Gouda by Artikaas
- Smoky Bacon Cheddar by Cabot Creamery Cooperative
- Smoky Pepper by Cello
- Smooth Blue by Daphne's Creamery
- Snow Camp by Goat Lady Dairy
- Snowy Cheddar by Daphne's Creamery
- Sofia by Capriole Goat Cheese
- Soft Goat Cheese Cranberry Cinnamon by Primo Taglio
- Soft Goat Cheese Fig & Olive by Primo Taglio
- Soft Goat Cheese Garlic & Herb by Primo Taglio
- Soft Goat Cheese Truffle by Primo Taglio
- Somerset Red by Ivy's Reserve
- Sonoma Blue by Sonoma Cheese
- Special Select Dry Monterey Jack by Vella Cheese Co.
- Spicy Habanero by Sach Foods
- Spicy Smoked Gouda by Red Apple Cheese
- Spinach Artichoke Gouda by Roth Cheese
- Spring Truffle Pecorino by Boar’s Head
- Sriracha Gouda by Boar’s Head
- Sriracha Jack by Meister Cheese
- Steakhouse Onion by Yancey's Fancy
- Stella Vallis by Chaseholm Farm
- St. Germain by Blakesville Creamery
- Stinky Ewe by Nettle Meadow Farm
- St. James by Alemar Cheese Company
- St. Stephen by Four Fat Fowl
- Suffolk Punch by Parish Hill Creamery
- Sugar Loaf by Nettle Meadow Farm
- Sunny Ridge by Blakesville Creamery
- Suprême Brie by Marin French Cheese
- Sweet Annie by Landmark Creamery
- Sweet Fire Chèvre by Portland Creamery
- Sweet Fire Mango by Meister Cheese
- Sweet Heat by Bear State Farms
- Sweet Heat Cheddar by Kretschmar
- Sweet Red Grass Fed Cheddar by Barber's
- Swiss by Maytag Dairy Farms
- Swiss by Tillamook Creamery
- Swiss by Lucerne
- Swiss by Beemster
- Swiss Gruyère by Primo Taglio